Moving to City Island, made easy

Get housing costs, school ratings, safety rankings, walkability scores,
and more with our ultimate City Island guide.

A charming small town completely secluded from the hustle and bustle of the city.
Studio / 1 BR
67% Complete
2 Bedrooms
80% Complete
3 Bedrooms
86% Complete
4 Bedrooms
100% Complete

Good For
  • Empty nesters / Retirees
  • Families
  • Singles


What's around
  • 33 Restaurants
  • 2 Schools
  • 5 Grocery stores/markets
  • 1 Banks
  • 4 Nightlife options
  • 12 Fitness options
  • 19 Shops




City Island has a below average violent crime rate and a low property crime rate for New York City.


Planning your move to a new city has never been easier! Don't let the unknown costs hold you back - use moveBuddha's Move Estimate Tool to get a personalized, instant moving estimate in just a few clicks. Make an informed decision, and confidently embark on your exciting new adventure. Try it now and experience a seamless transition to your dream city!

It's hard to believe that you're within the boundaries of New York City when you spend time on City Island. It feels like a secluded fishing village in the northeast, not a neighborhood in one of the biggest cities in the world. Residents speak of feeling like they're always on vacation in this bucolic place with a small town vibe. Kids can walk around without supervision without parents feeling paranoid.

This becomes a bustling destination for other New Yorkers during summer, who come for the great seafood restaurants and quaint shops located on the main corridor through town, City Island Avenue. But in winter it returns to the residents and the quiet – and the people who live here love that time.

You'll find a mix of empty nesters and younger people looking for a slower-paced lifestyle and affordable homes. And regardless of age, it's a popular spot for boating enthusiasts. Many people here own boats and there are several yacht clubs on the island – a fitting tribute to the island's past as a center for boatbuilding.

Housing-wise, there's a mix of cottages, bungalows, Victorian-style homes, shingled homes, and a few new developments. Some properties boast views of the Manhattan skyline.

Residents will be signing up for a fairly long commute into Manhattan, though it is faster to head to northern business hubs like White Plans and Stamford via car. You'll also have to contend with the fact that there's only one way on or off the island via a bridge; during commuting hours this quickly gets jammed up with traffic.

City Island is bordered on all sides by the Long Island Sound.


Wall Street: 20.1 miles / 50-90 minutes by car / 90-100 minutes by transit
Rockefeller Center: 16.2 miles / 50-80 minutes by car / 80 minutes by transit
Stamford: 23.8 miles / 35-55 minutes by car / 100 minutes by transit

City Island New York City Neighborhood Photo


Local Flavor   City Island LOCAL schools

Ps 175 City Island
Parent Rating:
Distance:0.24 mi
St Mary Star Of The Sea School
Parent Rating:
Distance:0.54 mi


Photo Credits: Thanks to @laura_peruchi, @jacksbait, @johnkyan, @birchp, @mztazblue, @juniitosofficialpage, @gileventsur, @szabyvett, @claptracks, @mastermoo, @maudeswift, @nujerze523, @takeapickcha, @esantana, @kathleenmziegler, and @avrabel for your great photos of this neighborhood! 


Do you have photos you'd like to share? Send 'em in to

Move here from anywhere.

Get free quotes from awesome international movers.
Compare all your quotes in one place. Book the right mover for you.

You might also like...
Or get personalized neighborhood recommendations from our Neighborhood Explorer
have anything to add? Are you a local expert? We're always looking for the best intel on neighborhoods, so send us a message if you have any tips
Desktop Version

© 2023 GoodMigrations LLC. All rights reserved.

The GoodMigrations logo and the Cost/Time/Condition metric are service marks of GoodMigrations LLC. Terms  Privacy Policy